Amy Tucci
Hi there. I’m Amy Tucci. I’m president Hospice Foundation of America, and I’m going to tell you a little bit about hospice care, a much misunderstood part of our healthcare system, and so here we go. First, I’ll tell you a little bit about the Hospice Foundation of America. We’ve been around since 1982. We work to improve care at the bedside through professional education, and we provide free and unbiased advice to people, and information to people who need information about hospice care and grief, or really, any kind of end of life care. Because of that, much of our work focuses around advanced care planning. We currently have a national project going on that’s looking at two advanced care planning tools, funded by NIH, and we’re about to have our 75th event. We are very proud of that project. We did a lot with some other advanced care planning, things such as being mortal. And right now we’re currently working with the Hello Game and the Conversation Project. We are not a hospice provider. There is no single hospice entity in the United States. There are 5000 hospice providers, all operating independently, but mostly, most all of them are working within the confines of the Medicare Hospice Benefit, which is the government sets the rules around hospice. So a little bit about hospice in the United States: Hospice has only been around for about 51 years in the United States in a formal way. And that started back in 1974 when the dean of Yale’s nursing school, Florence Wald, went to visit St. Christopher’s Hospice in Great Britain, and she came back and she decided that she wanted to set up the first actual hospice in the United States, which is the Connecticut Hospice in Branford, Connecticut, which is still around today. After this eight year period before Congress passed the Medicare Benefit, hospices were popping up all over the United States. Most of them were volunteer hospices. They were run by doctors and nurses and and the whole impetus for this was that people were starting to talk about death and dying, largely because of work of people like Elizabeth Kubler Ross, who wrote a very famous book called, “On Death and Dying” and it really started a wave, and that wave has continued. A poll in 1997 showed that most people did not want to die at a hospital. They wanted to die at home, and they wanted to die with their loved ones present, and next to things that they loved and were important to them. And so hospice has grown and grown. Now about half of all deaths in the United States occur under hospice care, and that includes deaths of every kind. So that’s including car accidents and things like that. Those people typically would not be hospice patients. But even including sudden deaths, it’s still half of all deaths. So the top seven diagnosis for hospice dying and reasons that people die in hospice, reasons that they’re referred to hospice, the number one reason today is Alzheimer’s disease and dementia. That’s changed recently. Cancer used to be the number one reason for referral to hospice, it’s no longer. Now it’s the third reason, and you can see the other top diagnoses here, kidney disease is a reason that people die in hospice, but people cannot receive dialysis while on hospice, and I’ll get into that a little bit later. So if somebody has kidney disease and is on dialysis, they would have to go off dialysis before going onto hospice. People are really confused about when hospice care is appropriate. Hospice care is appropriate – and it can only be accessed when a doctors opinion is that the prognosis for life is six months or less. That does not mean that somebody can only be in hospice for six months, but that is the way the door opens to hospice admission. Every illness has its own specific criteria for hospice admission, but it’s also when prognosis is very uncertain, so, and we see this a lot with Alzheimer’s disease, where the person may be referred to hospice, and the doctor may think that the person has six months or less to live, the person ends up coming onto hospice, being discharged from hospice, going back onto hospice, and the reason they’re discharged is if they no longer meet the medical criteria for hospice, the government requires that they be discharged so that can set up a real uncomfortable situation for families, and it’s something that I hope the government is doing something to fix. We certainly would support anything like that. When treatment is that was aimed at curing or stabilizing is no longer effective. That’s another time that hospice would be appropriate. But of course, it always comes with the doctors evaluation as well. And if a patient no longer desires cured treatment and really wants to shift from cure to quality. My mother died of a glioblastoma, and when she had gone through radiation and chemotherapy, even though she had an inoperable brain tumor, they did do some palliative treatment before she entered hospice, but she made the decision when she just could not face going back to radiation and chemo again because it was making her so sick and ruining the quality of her life. So she went onto hospice about seven months before she died, the doctor had thought that she had three months, three weeks or less to live when she was admitted to hospice, but she ended up really having a wonderful six month to seven month period on hospice where our family was around her and we had really wonderful moments that we could share together. I think she would have died much sooner if she had continued the radiation and chemotherapy, and people choose hospice also when, just like as my mother did, when the goal becomes symptom management and other types of care that hospice can provide. So for cancer patients, the palliative performance scale is often used by doctors to determine whether their patient is eligible for hospice and patients who meet the standard are unable to, really participate in normal activity or do normal work. They’re unable to move well, spend about 50% of their time in bed or in a chair or in a single room. They have evidence of significant disease. They have a hard time taking care of themselves by themselves, and they have a reduced nutritional intake due to appetite loss or other disease characteristics. So the overall goal of hospice is to improve the quality of life for patients and families facing terminal illness, and they really treat the the entire person, and they also treat the entire family, so they’re providing psychosocial support the family. They can even provide grief support before death to both the patient and the family, because, as I think it was Omni, I think mentioned that the loss process is something that starts long before death, and so hospice is there for the person in those ways. Another thing that people don’t understand about hospice, and I always think it’s very important that they do understand it, is that the family is typically heavily involved in hospice care. It is by no means a requirement that a hospice patient has a family member who’s a primary caregiver, but it is something that is pretty standard in hospice and family caregivers do a lot of work when they have a family member who is in hospice care. It can be a big adjustment for family members and hospice is there to support that, but it’s something that people should know about hospice, and for our family, it gave us, as I said, just a wonderful opportunity to be together in my mother’s final months of life. But it does take a commitment to want to be a caregiver. The hospice staff makes regular visits to assess the patient, adjust medications and do other things. For example, a certified nursing assistant will help the patient bathe or bathe the patient, if necessary. The hospice will provide all the durable medical equipment necessary, so hospital bed, if that’s desired and necessary, oxygen, any other kind of equipment that might be necessary that’s all fully covered under Medicare and Medicaid and most private insurance also covers all of the cost of hospice or very few out of pocket expenses. A lot of people ask, how many times does a nurse come every week? The average is three times a week. If somebody is admitted to hospice and is has a terminal prognosis, that’s the only way they’d be admitted to hospice. But oftentimes people are not. They don’t need a nurse three times a week. You know, maybe they need a nurse once a week, and maybe they need a social worker twice a week and a chaplain once a week, and I’ll get to the members of the hospice team in a second. So the hospice staff is always on call 24 hours a day. So that means that a nurse and a physician should always be available to come to the house if necessary. Most hospice care is delivered in a person’s home. A person’s home is defined very broadly by hospice. It can be private residence, it can be a nursing home, it can be an assisted living facility, depending on the assisted living facility’s rules. A hospice team consists of registered nurses, therapists such as speech therapists, physical therapists, occupational therapists, hospice aides who are usually certified nurse assistants, brief counselors, social workers, physicians, chaplains, and last but not least, certainly, our volunteers. Volunteers are there to provide and be able to do things like run run errands for the family, or they can also do things like mow the lawn, walk the dog, or just sit with a patient, read to the patient, give a family member who’s providing care a break from caregiving so they can go out and do something that they want to do. Hospices, all hospices that participate with Medicare have to have 5% of their patient care hours they have to certify have been provided by volunteers. So overall, the services that are provided include the number one thing, which is to manage patients’ pain and any other symptoms that go along with that pain, and that can range from spiritual pain to physical pain. They provide the medications and medical equipment. Many hospices deliver the medications to the patient’s home. They instruct the family how to care for a patient, how to help a patient, for example, get out of bed, how to move them to the toilet, those sorts of things that are really important when you’re a caregiver. As I said, they’ll help with bathing and when, or if symptoms are cannot be managed at home, then there they can arrange for inpatient care or 24 hour care by a nurse at home. Okay, I talked to you about the speech and physical therapy occupational therapy, if it can improve the quality of life for a patient, this is something that the hospice will provide. In my mother’s case, for example she lost her ability to speak, and the speech therapist came and helped her speak for a little bit longer, and it was very, very helpful. And so, and though we have on this slide, it’s rare. It’s actually gaining more and more traction. It is something that’s required by the the Medicare regulations, and there are many hospices that have really embraced it recently and are offering physical therapy and occupational therapy, in particular, speech and to their patients, because it does improve their quality of life, and that with speech therapy, this is often necessary for people with Alzheimer’s because it involves swallowing. So it’s a very valuable service that hospice can provide, and hospice also provides grief support. It’s required to provide 12 months of grief support after a death, but that grief support can happen prior to death, and it is often something that patients and families take advantage of prior to death. There are four levels of hospice care. There’s routine hospice care, which is the care that’s the sort of the basic hospice care, which is the care that’s at home, where the nurse will come and and other members of the hospice team will come to the person’s home, or wherever they’re living. There’s continuous home care, which is a step up, which would be a registered nurse, being at the home for much greater periods during the day if pain couldn’t be managed by the family and by the prescriptions that were available to the family. There’s inpatient respite care, which particularly if somebody is on hospice for an extended period of time, it can give the caregiver a break, and so some hospices will provide that by sending somebody to a person’s home, and some hospices the person is moved to a nursing home or a hospital for the period the hospice patient is moved there for a period of five days, where when the the caregiver can can get away, maybe the caregiver needs surgery or needs to go to a wedding or something like that, so that is available. And then finally, general inpatient care is when the pain and other symptoms cannot be managed at home. That occurs in either a hospice inpatient setting, which might be a building that’s owned by the hospice where the person is transported for a short period of time, hopefully, until the pain symptoms are managed, and then the person is returned to their home, in some cases, or someone will die in that environment, and in some cases, it’s not the same level of care, but there are a few hospices, not many, that have residential facilities. So in those situations, that’s not considered a level of care. But in those situations, somebody would be paying for their room and board at the facility, and their hospice care would be covered by insurance.
Hospice care can really last pretty indefinitely, as we saw with President Carter, who I think was received hospice care for at least two years. The average is 97 days, median of 18 days, and very few patients, only about 10% are receiving hospice care for more than 280 or so days, seven days, if, as I mentioned earlier, if the person is considered hospice ineligible, because their health either improves, or they decide to seek curative treatment, or they decide to cease to say, enter a clinical trial, then they would be discharged from hospice, and they can return to hospice at any time after being discharged, as long as they are medically appropriate for it. I’m just speaking briefly about grief support. Hospice is the only part of our US healthcare system that does provide grief support. Many hospices provide grief support even if the family member who is being grieved did not die in the care of hospice. And volunteers are a very important part of hospice care. And as I mentioned, about 5% of hospice care is provided by volunteers. So we get the question a lot about what’s different about palliative care and hospice care, because these terms are often used interchangeably. Palliative care is part of hospice care. It’s probably the biggest part. That’s what hospice care is all about, is to provide palliative care, which is the management of pain and symptoms. But hospice as a benefit, differs from palliative care, because when you’re receiving palliative care, you can continue to pursue curative treatment, which you cannot do when you’re receiving hospice care. Palliative care is often provided on an outpatient basis, instead of in-home setting. That too is changing. Many hospices are now offering palliative care before a hospital patient is hospice eligible and it really depends on the hospice, and often how big the hospice is, but it’s more and more often available. Palliative care is often available from a hospice provider. However, it is not reimbursable in the same way that hospice care is reimbursable as a package of services. I can answer any questions about palliative care as well. People often ask us about radiation, chemotherapy and immunotherapy while receiving hospice and if the radiation and chemotherapy is cure oriented. That is not allowable on hospice according to the government rules, however, many hospices will cover radiation and chemotherapy for their patients, as long as it has a therapeutic effect. So if it is improving the life of a patient, and if for example, the patient might have an esophageal tumor, and the patient’s quality of life is much improved by the radiation that is shrinking that tumor that will be allowed. In chemotherapy much more selectively, and I will say that the bigger hospice is, the more able they are, the more resources they are to provide these additional treatments. Immunotherapy is not permitted while in hospice, but that may change at some point. Consumer Assessment for Healthcare Providers and Systems found in the survey they did that the number one complaint that families have about hospice care is that they didn’t know when they could get it and they didn’t take advantage of it soon enough. From our experience talking to literally 1000’s of people every year about hospice care, we have found that people, the longer they can take advantage of hospice care, the happier they are with hospice care. You don’t want to get into a situation where the oncologist is, dialing 911, for hospice. Hospice is not an emergency kind of healthcare. It’s a healthcare that is more like, slow healthcare, and so I always encourage people to look into it even before they think it might be time. We tell people, “don’t wait for your physician to bring it up”. Oncologists went to medical school to cure people of things that they can always cure them of, and the same with with every other doctor that is in the business of curing. And so I think there’s a reluctance sometimes with physicians, to acknowledge that treatment isn’t working like they wanted it to, and they keep trying new things and doing new things. But it’s important to let your doctor know if you’re interested in hospice care, and talk to your loved ones about it as well. It may not be time, right? It might not be time, and may be far, like three years away from even thinking about hospice or needing hospice. But if it’s on the radar screen, at least you’re ready, and your loved ones are too. So like I said, start the conversations with loved ones and medical providers. You can also self refer to a hospice. So if your physician is saying, “No, I don’t think it’s time for hospice.” it’s possible to make a phone call to hospice and ask for an evaluation. They will, in turn, speak with your doctor and review medical records as well. And in terms of choosing a hospice, oftentimes physicians are good referral sources to a hospice, or a physician will refer to a specific hospice, but you can always choose the hospice that you want to use. It’s like any other kind of health care. Ask families and friends if they’ve had experience with a hospice. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid has a helpful tool that’s called care “Compare”. It’s not perfect, but it does provide family ratings. So hospice care, it’s searchable, so you can search by zip code to find all the hospice providers, almost all the hospice providers in your area. If a hospice is very small, it won’t be listed on Compare. You can also visit with hospice providers. You can ask a hospice provider to come to your home to talk to them. There’s no cost. You can interview the hospice. On our website, we have questions to ask a hospice about the kind of care they provide and what their standards are, and even though there are some basic standards, every hospice is going to have a slightly different personality, and maybe that personality is not going to mesh with your personality, but it’s important to talk to the hospice that’s going to provide care to make sure that you’re in line. Now, if you do have a hospice that that is providing care and you don’t like it, and that’s possible, you can change providers. And this happens with some, not a lot of frequency, but it happens, and in that case, the hospice that is providing care is required to work with a hospice that’s assuming care and make it as seamless as possible. So this is our website. We also have a free service where we have a nurse practitioner who is certified in hospice and palliative care. She answers personally herself, all of the questions that come in through our website. We receive dozens of questions every day, and we answer all the questions confidentially, and we try to answer everything within 24 hours. Get Palliative Care is an excellent resource, also about which provides a directory of palliative care programs. We were funded to produce a movie which can be watched on our website, called, “Hospice – Something More” that follows several people through the hospice experience, and it’s just a beautiful movie, and I encourage you to watch it when you have time. And that is it for me.